Saturday, May 22, 2021

Because or despite

 Today’s musing minute 

Because or despite. 

The plea to “listen to science” seems both noble and sensible, as in, what to do about covid-19. But the “science” never, by itself, gives us a complete answer about what to do. And that is true even if we are agreed on the objective we want to achieve. This is because the “science”, the facts, never speak for themselves – and that is even if we agree on what the relevant facts are. The reason is facts need to be interpreted, and interpretation is a tricky business – subjective, dependent on prior knowledge and experience, including what one has been taught, what one believes is the correct framework of interpretation. The *framework of interpretation* is key. 

At the heart of the ambiguity is the role of counterfactuals, the “what might/would have been”. The same set of facts in the social world (district from the facts of natural science where controlled experiments are often possible) are often interpreted in diverse, often diametrically opposed, ways. This is the “because or despite” phenomenon. 

Example: What was the cause of the 2008-9 financial crisis? Two popular answers are 1 or 2.

  1. Insufficient regulation of financial activities (the counterfactual claim: if speculation and greed and been properly regulated it would not have occurred – it occurred *because* of insufficient regulation). 
  2. Too much regulation of financial activities (the counterfactual claim: if mortgages had not been subsidized and capital flows distorted by mortgage regulations to increase homeownership it would not have occurred – it occurred *despite* substantial regulation (and actually *because* of that regulation)). 

Another example: What explains the amazing increase in global wealth 1945 – 2015? Two possible answers are 1 and 2. 

  1. The appropriate expanding role of wise government policy (Keynesian economics and “market-failure” regulation) – it occurred *because* of expanding regulation – the counterfactual claim being, absent which it would not have occurred. The regulation is a tailwind.
  2. The expansion of world trade *despite* the inhibiting costs of expanding government regulation – absent which it would have been even greater. The regulation is a headwind. 

The vast majority of disagreements about economic policy and public administration are like this. They revolve around opposed interpretive frameworks, in particular, frameworks that see the effects of government policy in opposite ways, and, therefore point to diametrically opposed implications for the appropriate role and scope of government intervention in the economy. Constructive (even civil) conversation is impeded by the difficulty of deciding which of any competing counterfactual claims is the most likely. Sometimes the evidence weighs heavily in favor of one or another, but often not.

A significant example is the very idea of Socialism. The “science” tells us that wherever it has been attempted it has failed miserably (without exception), unless you believe that it actually has never been implemented properly (counterfactual claim: What started in Venezuela, N. Korea, China or Russia as socialism, deteriorated into dictatorship. This need not have happened, and if it had been “done properly” socialism would have been a success. Therefore we conclude the science does not tell us it is doomed to fail. Bravo Bernie! So much for the science.

2 comments:

CARAMEL JOHNSON said...

HILLTOP FINANCE DARLEHEN


HILLTOP ist die Nummer eins unter den Kreditunternehmen, die bereit sind, Ihnen alle Arten von Krediten zu gewähren, egal wie schlecht Ihre Kreditwürdigkeit ist. Haben Sie sich Sorgen gemacht, wo Sie das zusätzliche Geld bekommen können? Beeilen Sie sich jetzt und kontaktieren Sie uns unter hilltopfinancefirm@gmail.com, um ein fantastisches Kreditangebot zu erhalten.

Ein Darlehen zur einfachen Tilgung Ihrer Schulden?
Ein Darlehen, um die Art von Geschäft zu starten, die Sie tun möchten?
Ein Darlehen für Bildungszwecke?
Ein Darlehen, um eine Wohnung zu kaufen?
Ein Darlehen, um dieses Traumauto zu kaufen?

HILLTOP FINANCE bietet all diese Kredite mit an
Keine versteckten Zahlungen und sehr wenig Papierkram.
Wir bieten Darlehen zwischen 5.000 und 20.000.000 EUR / USD / Pfund an
Bei einem sehr niedrigen Zinssatz von 5%.
Kunden weltweit schätzen unsere Bemühungen
Und wir können Ihnen versichern, dass wir die Besten sind.
Wir bemühen uns, unseren Exzellenzstandard zu halten
Anbieten unserer Dienstleistungen zu jeder Tageszeit.

Machen Sie noch heute den mutigen Schritt und kontaktieren Sie uns
Wenn Sie ein Darlehen oder eine finanzielle Unterstützung benötigen und
Ihre positiven Erwartungen werden überaus erfüllt.

E-Mail: hilltopfinance@protonmail.com

E-Mail: hilltopfinancefirm@gmail.com

WhatsApp: +1 954 417 1149

Mit herzlicher Rücksichtnahme

CARAMEL JOHNSON said...

HILLTOP FINANCE LOANS


HILLTOP is the number one loan company willing to grant you all types of loans, no matter how bad your credit score is. Have you been worried looking for where to get that extra cash, hurry now and contact us at hilltopfinancefirm@gmail.com to get an amazing loan offer.

A loan to pay off your debt easily?
A loan to start the kind of business you want to do?
A loan for educational purposes?
A loan to buy an apartment?
A loan to buy this dream car?

HILLTOP FINANCE offers all these loans with
No hidden payments and very little paperwork.
We offers loan ranging from 5,000 to 20,000,000 EUR / USD / POUNDS
At a very low interest rate of 5%.
Customers worldwide appreciate our efforts
And we can assure you, we are the best.
We strive to maintain our standard of excellence
Offering our services at any time of the day.

Take that bold step today and contact us
If you need a loan or financial assistance and
your positive expectations will be met exceedingly.

email: hilltopfinance@protonmail.com  

email: hilltopfinancefirm@gmail.com

whatsapp: +1 954 417 1149

With warm consideration